Michigan Gardener

SIGN UP to stay in touch!
We will send you occasional e-mails with gardening tips and information!


Digital Editions

Click on the cover to read now!

  • Home
  • Departments
    • Ask MG
    • Books
    • Clippings
    • Garden Snapshots
    • MG in the News
    • Janet’s Journal
    • Plant Focus
    • Profile
    • Raising Roses
    • Thyme for Herbs
    • Tools and Techniques
    • Tree Tips
  • Garden Event Calendar
  • Resources
    • Alternatives to Impatiens
    • Garden Help
    • Soil and Mulch Calculator
    • Public Gardens
  • Web Extras
  • About
    • About Us
    • Editorial Content
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact Us
Home Tree Tips Oak trees: Problems and solutions

PLEASE NOTE: In the autumn of 1995, we hatched the idea for a free, local gardening publication. The following spring, we published the first issue of Michigan Gardener magazine. Advertisers, readers, and distribution sites embraced our vision. Thus began an exciting journey of helping our local gardening community grow and prosper.
After 27 years, nearly 200 issues published, and millions of copies printed, we have decided it is time to end the publication of our Print Magazine and E-Newsletter.

Oak trees: Problems and solutions

May 20, 2009   •   15 Comments

by Steve Turner

While there are many types of oak trees out there, they can all be broken down into two groups: white or red. This will be important to keep in mind as we discuss the problems they face. The easiest way to distinguish the two is by the tips of the lobes on their leaves. If they come to a point, they are in the red oak family. If they are smooth and rounded, they are from the white oak family. While both groups are vulnerable to most of the same problems, the seriousness will differ. For instance, oak wilt is always fatal in red oaks, but is treatable in white oaks. We will cover the problems in order from most to least serious.

Sudden oak death is as bad as it sounds. It is a disease caused by a strain of a common fungus that will often only cause minor leaf blotches on other types of plants. When introduced to oaks, however, it will cause a very quick demise of the tree. Bleeding cankers that ooze a black, resin-like substance are the calling card of this disease. The tree dies shortly thereafter.

The good news is that it has yet to be found in Michigan. So far it has been confined to the West Coast, mainly northern California and the Pacific Northwest. The bad news is that those are areas that ship many plants to the Midwest.

The odds of this disease coming here on an alternative host and then infecting our native oaks is pretty high, judging by the spread of these types of problems in the past. I’m afraid it is more of a question of when, not if, it will get here. Only by asking for and buying only Midwestern-grown stock can we help reduce the chance that this (and other invasive organisms) ends up here in the long run. At this time there is no known cure for this disease.

Next is oak wilt, also caused by a fungus. It blocks the vascular system of the trees, causing them to wilt and die, very similar to Dutch elm disease (DED). Just like DED, it is spread by an insect and by root grafts. The good news is that the picnic beetle that helps spread the fungus is not as proficient as the bark beetles that spread DED. So, following simple cultural practices, such as never pruning oaks during the growing season, and promptly repairing and sealing any wounds caused by storm damage can greatly reduce the odds of trees being infected.

However, if your neighbors or utility companies don’t follow these same guidelines and nearby trees become infected, then oak wilt can spread through root grafts to your trees. As mentioned earlier, only white oaks can be cured if they become infected. In red oaks, you can only treat as a preventative measure and just like DED, they are still vulnerable to root grafts whether they are treated or not.

The only way to prevent infection through root grafts is to trench and sever the root systems between healthy and infected trees. If you have red oaks in areas where there are known infestations and they are important landscape trees, it would be wise to take a preventative approach.

Anthracnose is a foliar disease that causes browning of leaves from the veins outward, not to be confused with leaf scorch, which causes a similar effect, but from the edges inward. Anthracnose infects trees in the spring and the damage will appear during the growing season. It seems to infect white oaks much worse than red oaks.

Severely damaged leaves will generally fall off, leaving the tree looking sparse. Often the tree will try to put out new leaves to replace the damaged ones. If the tree has been infected for several years, it has a more difficult time finding the extra energy to do so year after year.

This is the point at which a normally mild disease can start to threaten the health of these trees by weakening them enough so that other organisms such as chestnut borers can enter the tree and cause their demise. Severely infected trees can either be injected in the fall or sprayed in the spring to help control this disease.

Late season frosts are not a disease, but they can cause disease-like problems for white oaks, which tend to leaf out a little later than red oaks, making the young leaves more vulnerable to the freezing temperatures. Generally the leaves will turn black and drop off or become distorted, with dead areas surrounded by healthy ones. If it happens often enough, it can lead to the same results as anthracnose, causing the tree to weaken over the years.

Iron chlorosis (iron deficiency) is also not a disease but an environmental condition that is very common in red oaks, especially pin oaks. It is not caused by lack of iron in the soil, but by the pH of the soil being too alkaline, causing the iron to be bound up in the soil and unavailable for the tree roots to absorb.

There are several ways to address this problem. A short-term solution is a trunk injection of iron to supplement what the tree cannot get on its own. This will only last 1 to 3 years depending on the situation.

More permanent solutions include: 1) adding chelated iron to the soil; this is a special kind of iron that will allow the tree to absorb it regardless of the pH, or 2) replacing soil around the tree by blowing out the high pH soil with a special tool and replacing it with better, more acidic soil, similar to replacing the soil of an ailing houseplant. This method will last many years, but is not always feasible in all situations (if access to the root zone is limited by structures or pavement). Left untreated, a tree will slowly starve to death over many years as photosynthesis is reduced by the lack of iron.

So, if you have an ailing oak, it would be wise to have it checked out sooner rather than later to determine what might be affecting it and to select the best course of action to help it recover. We owe it to these magnificent trees that have served mankind so well for thousands of years and helped shape our evolution.

Steve Turner is a Certified Arborist from Arboricultural Services in Oakland County, Michigan.

Filed Under: Tree Tips

Previous Post: Oaks: The king of trees
Next Post: Plant Focus: Fan Flower

Comments

  1. Shane Solomon says

    May 18, 2012 at 5:37 pm

    At the base of the oak tree the is a tunnel like hole in the middle about 3-4 inches wide. When I stick a stick in it it goes Almost half way through. There is ground up wood at the front of the hole. Is it insects maybe. How do I cure this problem?

    Reply
    • jhofley says

      May 21, 2012 at 9:57 pm

      Hard to say. If you are in Michigan, we recommend you contact your Extension service. They are staffed with master gardeners that can most likely answer your question. Our garden help page has a link to the extension services. Good luck!

      Reply
  2. Sylvia Norris says

    July 30, 2012 at 5:45 pm

    Two years ago I planted a memorial white oak tree in a conservation area in northern Illinois.
    I went to tend to it and noticed it has holes in the leaves, obviously something has infested it. How do I care for it

    Reply
    • jhofley says

      July 31, 2012 at 9:29 am

      Sylvia-
      Thanks for visiting our site. I think your best bet would be to obtain expert help in your area. A good place to start would be the Illinois Extension Service and their mater gardeners. You can find a guide by county here: http://web.extension.illinois.edu/mg/contact/default.cfm

      Good luck!
      -Jonathon

      Reply
  3. John Isaac says

    August 11, 2012 at 8:24 pm

    Is it possible for Japanese beetles to cause extensive leaf damage on a white oak planted 5 yrs. ago.

    Reply
    • jhofley says

      August 31, 2012 at 11:32 am

      John-
      I would recommend you contact your local extension service master gardeners for more information. If you are in michigan, you can find a directory of the extensions on our garden help page. Thanks for reading!
      -Jonathon

      Reply
  4. Linda says

    July 2, 2013 at 12:40 pm

    All of my oak trees are dropping a black material(looks like pepper). I would like to know if you know what this is and is it a problem? We have about a hundred trees and last year we had a drought. Thought maybe the hot summer and no water caused a problem. Thank you.

    Reply
    • jhofley says

      July 8, 2013 at 1:57 pm

      Linda-

      Unfortunately, we do not. But, we would recommend you get in touch with one of the following for an answer:
      1. Your local extension service. A list of Michigan’s are here.
      2. Your local independent garden center.
      3. A certified arborist in your area.

      Thanks for reading!

      -Jonathon

      Reply
  5. William Menges says

    June 1, 2014 at 4:42 pm

    I am noticing small, round pods, attached near leaves growing in clusters around the branches. (?) Most start with a green color then turn red. Some have tiny new leaves coming out of the pods.

    Can you explain this condition?

    Thank you WDM

    Reply
    • jhofley says

      June 3, 2014 at 9:28 am

      William-

      Hard to say but I would recommend you contact someone at your local independent garden center or contact your extension service which can be found here:

      http://msue.anr.msu.edu/county

      Thanks for reading!

      -Jonathon

      Reply
  6. Jerry Siepierski says

    August 13, 2016 at 3:49 pm

    I live in Newport Michigan. I have two old 75′ tall White Oak trees. I noticed three weeks ago (around the end of July), the leaves on both trees are turning black around the outer edges remaining green in the center of the leave and the leaves are falling off for the past several weeks. No new leave growth. Would you be so kind as to diagnose this condition.

    Thank you

    Jerry

    Reply
    • jhofley says

      February 21, 2019 at 11:01 am

      Jerry-

      Sorry, this comment got past us but we wanted to reply. We always recommend that you contact a certified arborist to come out and evaluate your tree in-person. This is the best way to obtain an accurate dignosis. Best of luck!

      -Jonathon

      Reply
  7. Matthew Pelt says

    March 25, 2017 at 10:50 am

    i have a oak tree in the front yard. Most winters it keeps its leafs all winter then loses them in the spring. this year it did just that but the branches have all turned a dark black only on the top side. what is going on

    Reply
    • jhofley says

      April 18, 2017 at 10:08 pm

      Matthew-

      It’s hard to say. I would recommend you contact a certified arborist in your area or reach out to your county extension service. See link below for a list of extensions. Thanks for reading Michigan Gardener!

      -Jonathon

      http://msue.anr.msu.edu/county

      Reply
  8. ralph pardue says

    July 25, 2018 at 7:14 am

    few yeara ago about ten I planted two red oaks on the same day both trees are healthy but one tree has a lilghter leaf and will drop leaves first it will also put on leaves first in the springs .both trees are the same size.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Copyright 1996-2025 Michigan Gardener. All rights reserved.